Penarth school is criticised by Estyn inspectors
THE QUALITY of teaching and learning at Fairfield Primary School in Penarth has been strongly criticised in a report by inspections body Estyn, who have stated that it is in need of “significant improvement”.
The report has been published following an inspection at the school on Dryden Road in March. The school has 279 pupils, with 7.1% classed as having additional learning needs, below the Welsh average of 11.1%.
Inspectors criticised the school for not having a “clear, shared vision” for its curriculum that ensures pupils build their knowledge and understanding effectively across all areas of learning.
They found that teaching in around half of lessons does not develop or extend pupils’ knowledge and skills well enough. The report states: “The pace of learning is too slow, and teachers set tasks that do not challenge pupils sufficiently. Consequently, during their time in the school, many pupils do not make the progress they could…
“In around half of lessons, teachers’ expectations of what pupils should achieve are not ambitious enough. In these lessons, activities often lack a strong purpose and teaching proceeds at too slow a pace. Because of this, many pupils are not challenged sufficiently to build on what they already know or to apply their skills at a level that matches their ability.”
Just 3.3% of pupils at Fairfield Primary speak Welsh at home, and Estyn says that the school could do more to encourage use of the language. It says: “Pupils do not have enough opportunity to use or hear spoken Welsh and this restricts their progress…
“Teachers do not provide enough opportunities for pupils to develop their use of spoken Welsh effectively. Because of this, pupils’ understanding of Welsh is limited and the language has too little presence in the school.”
Senior teachers taken to task
Senior teachers and governors are taken to task by the inspectorate for multiple failings: “Leaders have not evaluated the quality of the school’s work robustly. They have not addressed important areas for improvement, such as the inconsistency in the quality of teaching and the effectiveness of the school’s curriculum, swiftly enough.
“Governors show strong support for the school. However, they do not have a thorough enough first-hand knowledge of the school to be able to challenge leaders effectively…
“Over time, leaders have not monitored the quality of teaching and learning rigorously enough to identify clearly what teachers do well and where teaching needs to improve. Consequently, they have not addressed inconsistencies in the quality of teaching or the rate of pupils’ progress.
“Responsibility for improvement is not shared effectively across the leadership team. This limits the school’s capacity to bring about necessary changes swiftly enough.”
Maths lessons criticised
The quality of mathematics lessons at the school was among the areas criticised in the report: “Teachers have recently adopted approaches to teaching that enable many pupils to make suitable progress in developing their mathematical understanding during lessons.
“However, teachers do not support pupils to apply their numeracy skills at an appropriate level in their work across the curriculum and this hinders their progress.”
Estyn highlights some positive attributes about Fairfield Primary, stating that it is a friendly and inclusive school where staff ensure that pupils feel happy and valued.
Pupils show respect for others
There is praise for the way in which nearly all pupils show respect for others, behave well and demonstrate positive attitudes to their learning.
Staff are commended for considering the views of pupils fairly and provide valuable opportunities to develop pupils’ leadership skills so that they contribute purposefully to the life of the school.
In need of “significant improvement”
Estyn states that Fairfield Primary is in need of “significant improvement” and has made four recommendations that it expects the school to implement ahead of a further monitoring visit in around 12 months’ time:
- Improve leadership at all levels and ensure that self-evaluation focuses closely on the most important aspects in need of improvement.
- Raise teachers’ expectations of what pupils should learn, know and understand and improve teaching to ensure that all pupils make the progress they should.
- Develop a coherent curriculum that supports pupils’ progress effectively.
- Improve pupils’ Welsh language skills.
Responding to the largely negative Estyn report, the Vale Council said: “It is extremely rare for a school in the Vale to be categorised as in need of significant improvement, with the vast majority meeting and often exceeding accepted standards.
“Some features of teaching at Fairfield were commended by assessors, but there were also areas where performance fell short.
“Inspectors noted that the school is friendly and inclusive and that pupils feel happy and valued. The report also recognised that nearly all pupils show respect for others, behave well and demonstrate positive attitudes to their learning.
“The fact pupils have opportunities to develop leadership skills is highlighted, while many were deemed to be capable readers who communicate their views and ideas through speech and writing effectively. Another observation was that staff are committed to securing the progress and wellbeing of all pupils and many teachers have benefited from professional learning, which is impacting positively on their ability to sustain progress.
“However, there were clear areas for attention which led to recommendations to improve the school’s leadership and teaching, to develop a clearer curriculum and raise Welsh language standards.
“Efforts to address these issues have already begun with a new Interim Executive Headteacher in place and a new Interim Head of School to be appointed shortly.
“A comprehensive Post-Inspection Action Plan (PIAP) has also been drawn up, which will guide work over the coming months to ensure rapid and sustained progress.
“The Governing Body has worked closely with the Local Authority to make these swift decisive changes, and both are confident they will have a significant positive impact.
“The new Interim Executive Headteacher will work with the school’s Leadership Team and wider staff body to drive improvement in the areas that need it.
“All concerned firmly believe this will have the desired effect and help Fairfield reach the high standards of other schools in the Vale.”
News, Letters, Sport and advertising are welcomed by the Glamorgan Star – the largest newspaper or magazine in the Vale of Glamorgan. Contact us today here.
.
- Burger King and Greggs new drive throughs are approved
- Affordable housing set for former Maesteg care home
- Council plans new future for former leisure centre
⭐ All of our social media in one handy place – here
Barry man jailed following brutal attack
Barry man jailed for threatening to kill woman
Uninsured driver was trafficking drugs
Welsh budget receives mixed response in Senedd chamber
MS calls for action on car racing in Llantwit Major
Cardiff Airport lose out to Corries













