AwarenessCouncil

Vale planning rules on phone masts has changed

THE leader of the Vale of Glamorgan Council has confirmed a major shift in policy when considering planning applications for new or replacement mobile phone masts, in line with Welsh Government guidance.

At last week’s Full Council meeting of the Vale Council, leader Cllr Lis Burnett (Labour, Stanwell) confirmed that in future, public health concerns would not be considered a valid reason for stopping the erection of a mobile phone mast, provided International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection [ICNIRP] guidelines have been met.

In April last year, Penarth Town Council refused permission for two telecom masts to be installed close to each other when it considered an application for a second mast in Elfed Avenue.

Glamorgan Star news - Cllr Mark Wilson. Photo: Vale Council.
| Cllr Mark Wilson.
Photo: Vale Council.

On that occasion, Cllr Mark Wilson (Labour, Stanwell), expressed his concerns about electromagnetic radiation for the residents of the street. Cllr Wilson is currently a Vale Council cabinet member with responsibility for Neighbourhood and Building Services.

Last August, some Cadoxton residents expressed anger at the installation of a 5G mast on a patch of grass at the junction of Bridge Street and Church Road, directly opposite Cadoxton Primary School. At 18 metres, the mast is around twice the height of nearby lamp posts.

Local resident Jacqueline Fyfe described it as an “eyesore” and also expressed concerns about potential public health risks.

Glamorgan Star news - Local residents (and pets) at the base of the mast in Cadoxton.
| Local residents (and pets) at the base of the mast in Cadoxton last August.

At last week’s Vale Council meeting, Cllr Burnett faced a question from a member of the public, Mr L Jones, who asked: “Do you all truly comprehend the dangers behind excess EMF exposure? i.e., all the 3, 4 and 5G mobile telecommunications masts? Who is signing off on the planning and safety as they are liable for damages? Who is signing off on these being installed on top of school buildings, hospitals, etc., or even being anywhere close to our children’s schools?”

‘Authorities should not consider the health aspects’

Glamorgan Star news - Cllr Lis Burnett. Photo: Vale Council.
| Cllr Lis Burnett.
Photo: Vale Council.

Signalling the change in policy in line with Welsh Government guidance, Cllr Burnett replied: “When considering planning proposals, the council must have regard to planning policy Wales, which states, and I quote, ‘provided that the development meets the ICNIRP, planning authorities should not consider the health aspects of mobile telecommunication equipment’.

“All new base stations are expected to meet the ICNIRP guidelines and again quote ‘planning authorities should not implement their own precautionary policies such as imposing a ban or moratorium on new telecommunications development or insisting on minimum distances between new telecommunications developments and existing developments’.

“In addition, the health and safety executive would be the enforcing authority for concerns about electromagnetic radiation in the telecommunications sector and I am aware that Public Health Wales has previously produced public health information on the subject. There is also UK guidance available.”

While online conspiracies about 5G masts spreading Covid have no scientific basis and can confidently be debunked, some experts are encouraging governments and councils to act with caution and stop the global roll out of 5G telecoms networks until more is known about the possible effects on public health.

Among those urging caution is Professor John William Frank from the Usher Institute at the University of Edinburgh, who in 2021 published an essay titled Electromagnetic fields, 5G and health: what about the precautionary principle? in which he said that 5G uses much higher frequency radio waves (RF-EMFs) than in the past and it relies on very new and relatively unevaluated supportive technology to enable higher data transmission capacity.

Professor Frank points out that permitted maximum safety limits for RF-EMF exposure vary considerably around the world, and that ‘5G systems’ is not a consistently defined term, comprising quite different specific technologies and components. In his essay, he says: “It is highly likely that each of these many forms of transmission causes somewhat different biological effects – making sound, comprehensive and up-to-date research on those effects virtually impossible.”

In conclusion, Professor Frank says that there is no compelling public health or safety rationale for the rapid deployment of 5G, and that main gains being promised are either economic, possibly for some more than for others, or related to increased consumer convenience.

⭐ All of our social media in one handy place – here

Glamorgan Star news - To advertise with the Glamorgan Star call us.
| CLICK ABOVE TO PROMOTE YOUR BUSINESS IN THE VALE’S LARGEST PRINTED NEWSPAPER.
Glamorgan Star news. 33,000 readers.
| SEND YOUR NEWS, LETTERS OR SPORT TO THE BEST READ NEWSPAPER IN THE VALE!

Glamorgan Star news

Founded in early 2021 by ex-Glamorgan GEM staff following its closure during the Covid pandemic. Now, the largest circulated, printed, newspaper or magazine in the Vale of Glamorgan.

Related Articles

Back to top button